Rachael Leigh Cook

Erin

Sam Page

Sam

Patrick Thomas O'Brien

Chuck

Bailey Stender

Debbie

Ahmed El-Mawas

Archie

T. Mychael Rambo

Santa

Sarah Agnew

Mayor

Kathryn Fumie

Maria

Rod Kasai

Taylor

Mika Flanagan

Olivia

Melinda Kordich

Diana

Chase Marcotte

Jonah

Jim Cunningham

Lou

Greta Oglesby

N.P. General Counsel

Agatha Rae Pokrzywinski

Bakery Worker

Rae Dastoor

Bakery Owner

Jake Lieder

Radio Intern

Christina Goltare

Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Gwen Ruhoff

Elf Council member (uncredited)

Dawan Scott

Tree Ceremony Attendee (uncredited)

Jesse Bakken

North Pole Elf (uncredited)

Bradley C. Daniels

Background (uncredited)

Mike Flaherty

Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Julie Goulette

Coffee Shop Patron / Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Dawn Jensen

Elf on Grand Council of Elves (uncredited)

Laura Judson

Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Tyler Kimber

Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Stacy Masog

Sleeping Woman in Jail (uncredited)

Emilio Medina

Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Chris Russ

Background (uncredited)

Amy Jo Schmidt

Elf Council Member (uncredited)

Lucretia Stillwater

Angry Woman in Jail (uncredited)